DEET Dissolves Breathable Fabrics: Experimental Results

I’m a skeptic by nature and have always questioned authority, standard operating procedures, gut feel, the status quo, and institutional knowledge. In work and at play, I often put these truths to the test by doing experiments or establishing quantifiable metrics that invariably show that long held beliefs are grossly incorrect.

Mountain Hardware Cohesion Pants

Does DEET Melt Synthetics?

I’d always heard that DEET dissolves breathable fabrics, such as Gore-Tex, and that you should keep the two from coming into contact with one other. I’ve never had this problem outdoors when I’ve used DEET, but I couldn’t pass up the opportunity to test whether it is true or a myth in a more controlled setting on a pair of breathable rain pants.

This winter, I managed to shred a pair of Mountain Hardware Cohesion Pants, slashing dozens of rips in the legs with sharp front points, while learning to use crampons. Mountain Hardware Cohesion Pants are made with Conduit DT, a proprietary Gore-Tex knockoff that has three layers: an outer shell layer made from Epic nylon, a middle breathable layer made from Conduit DT, and an inner Epic stretch liner. I tried to extend the life of these pants with duct tape (see above), but finally donated their remains to science, enabling this experiment.

DEET Concentrations

I applied three squirts of Ben’s 100% DEET and Ben’s 30% DEET to the Epic nylon fabric on the outside of the Cohesion pants. After 3 days, the 100% DEET solution (right in photo) was still quite wet, while the 30% DEET Solution (left in photo) had mostly dried. There was little evidence of any external damage to the pants leg.

 

Turning the pant leg inside out however, showed another result entirely. The 30% DEET solution had soaked through the outer shell layer and melted the middle Conduit DT layer and the inner liner. However, the damage was highly localized. [Does the photo below remind you of the Andromeda Strain?]

The damage under the 100% DEET application was much more significant, and large patches of the Conduit DT layer and the inner liner were melted away. As it turns out, this process is ongoing and the fabric continues to dissolve, unabated.

DEET Effects

The experimental evidence is quite clear and shows that DEET does dissolve breathable laminates. It’s true! However, the strength of the DEET solution that the laminate comes in contact with is a determining factor in the amount of damage that will occur. Therefore, hikers who are concerned about the impact of DEET to clothing made using breathable laminates are advised to dilute the point of contact with water to minimize potential damage.

Print Friendly

Tags

  • deet nylon
  • deet and nylon
  • conduit dt

, , , , , , , ,

9 Responses to DEET Dissolves Breathable Fabrics: Experimental Results

  1. Yeti February 20, 2009 at 7:31 am #

    Nice test bro!! I had heard this rumor a few years back but never had the stones to test it on my own gear. Thanks for the sacrifice and for sharing your results.

  2. Chad February 23, 2009 at 9:26 am #

    I recently discolored my plastic Highgear watch with bug-spray (just partial overspray from my arm). I'd guess it's a polypropylene material, but it could also be HDPE (high-density polyethylene). Care to expand your experimentation?

    I'm just keeping bug-spray away from my gear or using a liquid that can be rubbed directly into the skin without overspray.

    Great topic.

  3. Chris (i-cjw.com) February 23, 2009 at 6:01 pm #

    We salute those brave pants, which made the ultimate sacrifice in the name of scientific research! Good to know the rumor has some veracity.

  4. Earlylite February 23, 2009 at 6:32 pm #

    I've gotten a lot better at pointing my crampons since then. No rips for a while, now, with my newest pair of pants. :-)

  5. Earlylite February 25, 2009 at 5:10 am #

    Chad – sorry for the delay in approving your comment. You got trapped in my spam filter. Let me see if I have an old watch somewhere to expand the DEET test. Good idea for a series of posts – maybe I should call for donations.

  6. Brian Briggs January 12, 2012 at 3:53 pm #

    Thanks for using your gear. I’d heard this rumor and can say it’s true of tent fabric. The only thing good about deet is it keeps my allergy to the out doors from showing up in red spots and welts as it does when ever I try to use one of the new safe products on the market. Sure wish they could come up with something as effective as deet and as benign as skin so soft Oh, and without the grammy smell.

  7. Don January 12, 2012 at 5:09 pm #

    This comports with my own experience. Nylon is just fine (thank goodness for us climbers!) but other plastics are a crapshoot. It will melt plastic bags (making secondary containment a challenge) and is merciless toward swiss army knife handles.

    • Earlylite January 12, 2012 at 5:10 pm #

      Same with plastic watch faces – makes them foggy which is a real bummer.

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. The danger of DEET and synthetic fabrics | Out-Bush Australia - February 22, 2009

    [...] experiment consisted of spraying DEET on breatheable synthetic walking pants. The result of their experiment is eye-opening, with direct spraying of DEET (at both 100% and 30% concentrations) resulting in [...]

Leave a Reply