Liquid Fuel Stove Buyer’s Guide

Tuckermans Ravine

If you plan on winter camping or mountaineering, you should get yourself a liquid fuel stove that burns petroleum distillates like white gas or kerosene instead of a canister-based stove that burns isobutane fuel. Isobutane fuel will only burn at temperatures of 10-15 degree F or above, and does not generate enough heat to melt snow which is necessary for making drinking water in winter or at high altitudes. Liquid fuel is also more readily available internationally.

Liquid fuel stoves consist of a tank to hold the fuel, a pump to create pressure in the tank so the fuel will flow out through the fuel line, a valve to control fuel flow, and a burner where the gas mixes with air and burns.  Some stoves such as the Brunton AF can burn isobutane in canisters as well as liquid fuels but are priced at a premium and weigh far more than a canister-based stove.

All liquid fuel stoves burn a fuel called white gas. White gas is a very pure form of gasoline that does not contain any additives. Many liquid fuel stoves, particularly those intended for international (non-North American) use, also burn other dirtier forms of gasoline including kerosene, diesel, unleaded auto fuel, or jet fuel that are more readily available in places that do not stock specialized camping stove fuels. These other fuels share the high heat output and low temperature properties of white gas, but may clog your stove and increase the frequency in which you have to clean it. White gas is also self-priming, whereas other fuels such as kerosene require that you bring a second more volatile fuel such as primer paste or alcohol to prime them.

Some liquid stove manufacturers recommend that you use proprietary white gas formulations with their stoves such as Coleman Fuel, Optimus Artic Fuel, or MSR Superfuel. These are all branded variants of white gas.

There are quite a few liquid fuel stoves on the market. I've listed all the ones I could find below in a sortable table, including their weight (includes stove and pump, but not fuel bottle), the fuels they burn and their MSRP.

Some of these stoves listed, like the MSR Simmerlite, provide simmering capabilities. It is arguable that this is an unnecessary feature if you will just be using your stove to melt snow or boil water. If you plan on using your stove in the US or Canada, it is probably not necessary to pay a premium for the ability to burn fuels other than white gas. However, if you are traveling internationally, make sure to purchase a stove that lets you burn other fuels such as kerosene which are readily available in other parts of the world.

Stove(oz.)WGKerDieselAutoPrice
MSR XGX EX13.2YYY $149.95
MSR Whisperlite Intl.11.5YY  $79.95
MSR Whisperlite11.0Y   $69.95
MSR Simmerlite8.5Y   $99.95
MSR Dragonfly14.0Y   $129.95
Coleman Denali15.6YY Y$174.99
Coleman Feather 44224.0Y   $64.95
Optimus SVEA19.0Y   $99.95
Optimus Nova+14.9YYY $149.95
Primus Omni-Fuel19.0YYYY$144.95
Brunton Vapor AF16.0YYYY$179.95
Brunton Lander16.0Y   $148.95

Key:

oz: Weight, including includes stove and pump, but not fuel bottle
WG: White gas
Ker: Kerosene

Most Popular Searches

  • white gas stove
  • white gas stoves
  • liquid fuel stove

, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

12 Responses to Liquid Fuel Stove Buyer’s Guide

  1. Kevin January 8, 2009 at 5:39 am #

    I've owned the Whisperlite Internationale for quite a few years, and am always pleased with its performance. Burns just about any fuel you throw at it (some burn more efficiently and cleaner, of course) and is bomb-proof.

  2. Earlylite January 8, 2009 at 7:56 am #

    I'm leaning toward the MSR simmerlite myself. It's not a coincidence that it is the lightest in the bunch. I won't need the simmering function to melt snow, and I like the fact that you can clean the MSRs by shaking them. I don't know if that works, but it sounds easy. Stoves that require the purchase of an annual maintenance kit sound cranky.

  3. mrmatthewpaul January 8, 2009 at 10:36 am #

    How safe to use it in a tent To cook as well as warm the tent

    • Bill Schmurdle November 28, 2013 at 4:11 am #

      OK to use a stove inside your tent if you:
      a. Never spill anything
      b. Have a fireproof tent, and
      c. Can tolerate high levels of carbon monoxide.

      For the sake of clarity, I am being sarcastic as hell. NEVER fire up your stove in your tent unless you are desperate, and even then your tent must have an “expedition tent” vent.

  4. Earlylite January 8, 2009 at 11:48 am #

    Using white gas in a tent for cooking or warming is incredibly dangerous. I don't think you should ever do this. You are begging for death from a fireball or carbon monoxide poisoning. Seriously, russian roulette is safer.

  5. Chris (i-cjw.com) January 8, 2009 at 10:38 pm #

    On the subject of cannister stoves for winter, I wonder if you've seen the <a href"http://www.rei.com/product/769449&quot; rel="nofollow">JetBoil Helios system? The inverted cartridge means it draws off a constant propane/(iso)butane liquid mix – which means efficiency doesn't fall (as you don't simply end up burning off all the propane) – and there's very little evaporative energy loss to chill the catridge below its vapor point. The specs say it works to -10 degrees F.

    I'm a big fan of their PCS system (and can usually get it working well even in cold temperatures by keeping the catridge warm – you do need propane mix catridges though). I'm tempted to take a look at the Helios, and see if it can be converted for use with the PCS cup to lighten the load.

  6. Earlylite January 9, 2009 at 4:34 am #

    I've seen it, but haven't looked at it closely or tried it. I believe the theory behind turning the canister upside down is that it compensates for the pressure loss when your fuel gets low. I saw an article about this on BPL. In a liquid stove, you can compensate for this by pumping. Definitely worth a try since the safety improvement of canisters over white gas is indisputable. Nasty stuff that white gas.

  7. bigR January 12, 2009 at 6:48 pm #

    I have the Msr Dragonfly and if you look at the MSR site, it will burn about all types of fuel. It is a good stove, but maybe a little overkill and it sounds like a jet engine running.

  8. Tom Murphy March 24, 2009 at 5:05 am #

    I purchased a SVEA 123R this winter and am thrilled with it.

    It is heavy and loud.

    I carry an eye dropper to add the gas into the priming port so that I can prime it with the windscreen attached.

    I was camped in the backyard at -5 deg with a good wind and I was able to light off on the first try.

    Just a lot of fun.

  9. Earlylite March 24, 2009 at 11:18 am #

    I've been looking at the SVEA myself. Beautifully designed piece of equipment.

  10. tang-pommel July 21, 2009 at 1:14 pm #

    i have had the dragonfly since it first came out and still have it and take on trips up in the mountains it burnrns most fules unlike what the chart above says it dose iv even used naptha and trico ethylene with great sucsess and you shouldnt use any stove in a tent by rights having said that i have done it without turning myself into a fire ball and yes it dose sound like a jet engine when on full flame its scares the shit out of you the first time but you soon get used to it

  11. Mike April 25, 2010 at 8:21 pm #

    I've used a Svea 123 since the late 1970's. Have tried numerous other stoves over the years, but always choose the Svea when I go out for longer than an overnighter. Rock solid reliability and it produces plenty of heat to melt copious amounts of snow. I have a pump attachment but never use it, even in bitter cold. Only real drawback it it is a noisy bugger on a quiet morning!

Leave a Reply