Home / Backpacking Food / Milk is the New Gatorade

Milk is the New Gatorade

Dehydrated Milk Varieties are available for a lot of different dietary preferences
Dehydrated Milk Varieties are available for a lot of different dietary preferences

Milk is the new Gatorade for backpackers. At least dehydrated milk is. What other energy drink weighs so little but packs such a big punch in terms of calories and overall nutrition?

With a caloric density of 150 calories per once (dry), drinking a quart of whole milk will add 640 calories to your diet per day, in addition to loads of protein and electrolytes that hikers and backpackers have to work on getting enough of on long hikes. In liquid form, it goes down quick and doesn’t need a lot of preparation like cooked food.

Here’s a side-by-side head comparison of several varieties of milk vs. Gatorade to show you what you’ve been missing.

 Serving Size (g)Caloric density per ounce (dry)Calories per cup (liquid)Fat (g)Carbs (g)Protein (g)Sodium (mg)Potassium (mg)
Nido Instant Whole Milk301511609117105390
Myenberg Instant Whole Goat Milk281421407118115327
Instant Non-Fat Milk23111901.5188125390
Better-Than-Milk Instant Soy Milk239880012111525
Gatorade Orange Powder237460021014545

While Gatorade positions itself as an electrolyte replacement and energy drink, it’s basically just carbohydrates in the form of sugar, without the calorie rich fat and protein provided by milk. When compared side-by-side, Gatorade doesn’t even provide significantly more electrolytes than milk. Maybe, it’s time to get a milk mustache and toss your Gatorade into the hiker box.

Whole Milk

Chances are you grew up drinking regular whole milk after school with your cookies or to wash down a PB&J sandwich. Nido dehydrated whole milk is the most popular brand among long distance hikers and tastes great when mixed with cold spring water on a hot day. Anecdotal evidence has also shown a significant reduction in the number of thru-hikers who choke on Nutella/Flour Tortilla sandwiches when eaten with a cold cup of Nido whole milk.

Goat Milk

Lactose intolerant? Try Meyenberg dehydrated goat milk instead. While goat milk (like all natural milk) contains lactose, many people who react poorly to lactose don’t have the same problem with goat milk. Because of its digestibility, you may find it’s the perfect alternative. And it’s gluten free. (Remember if you have been clinically diagnosed with either true cow milk allergy or lactose intolerance be sure to consult your medical profession before drinking goat milk.)

Instant Non-Fat Milk

While instant non-fat milk is not as nutritious as whole milk and goat milk, it is much more widely available in small town grocery stores, which is a real consideration on long distance hiking trails. It’s also widely available in smaller stay-fresh envelopes, making it possible to buy in smaller quantities and more convenient to send to yourself in mail resupply boxes.

Soy Milk

If you don’t consume dairy products, you can also benefit by drinking Better-than-Milk Soy Milk. While it’s technically not milk, it’s a pretty good stand-in versus Gatorade. But if you’re a vegetarian or a vegan, you know all this already, right?

28 comments

  1. I love it! Nido pretty much revolutionized my summer hiking diet, especially after years of thinking dry milk was disgusting because of the non-fat stuff. How does the taste of the goat milk compare to nido? I’ve seen it in lots of grocery stores, but never tried.

  2. Nido is OK. None of the milk products actually provide enough salt on a warm day, though. They are mostly foods. Soo, don’t do away wit h Gatoraid quite yet.

    • Sorry Jim, but that claim doesn’t stand up to empirical scrutiny. There is no need to drink Gatorade if you eat foods that have salt in them, like salted peanuts, almonds, crackers, etc. Gatorade just doesn’t have as much salt as they’d like you to believe. It you want a ton of salt, eat, eat, eat. Do the label math.

    • I do not drink sports drinks such as Gatorade, read the label it is liquid junk food.
      Plenty of water, salted nuts or pretzels (Sodium) + dairy product such as cheese or powdered milk (potassium & calcium) = electrolytes. Additionally, trail food typically is high in sodium; I would be more concerned with the lower potassium and calcium content.

  3. We agree, but you’ve kind of missed the point Bruce. There’s no sodium or potassium in coconut milk and it’s not actually milk.

  4. “New” Well not to me..Been Carrying a packet of Nestle, or Bordens and now Wal-Mart brand powdered Milk for years…My Backpacking Doctor in about 1996? when I complaining about leg Cramps, we went over my Diet and first thing he told me was to get rid of the Gatorade type powders because of the sodium levels which are good if your hiking in HOT HUMID weather for which it was developed and the Milk and go with what they called back then Gookinade which was developed by a Cardiologist in San Diego, so I went to that and remarkably all my middle of the night leg cramps disappeared with just one Quart of mix after a 6 hour climb up the Eastern side of the Sierra’s.. I do continue to add a teaspoon or more of Powdered Milk to my Hot Chocolate, Mac&Cheese, Granola, and dehydraded Noodles and Chicken Stews,,I stop at adding it to my Tea,,,,cause I just can’t deal with it in my Tea,, Guess I’ll never be a true Irishman….

    • I forgot to add the current name of Gookinade…It is called “Hydralyte” Sports Drink…..and I still use it.. I like the “Fruit Punch” flavor the best..

  5. How refreshing that the solution almost always lies in imbibing whatever has been least altered by human intervention.

  6. Thanks for the informative article, Philip. My friend Lt. Dan uses Nido for his cereal. I’m going to buy a can and use it regularly on the trail. Easy calories, fat and protein to add to meals. How does it compare in vitamins? I’ve always thought that Gatorade was overrated… :)

  7. Since Gatorade was designed to replace what the body lost through exertion, I’ve always considered it to be lime flavored sweat. Can’t stand the stuff.

  8. In the arena of sports training, chocolate milk has been evaluated as a recovery drink by exercise physiologists and found to be one of the best options available. Therefore, in addition to caloric density and broad nutritional value, it is effective for hiking “performance” with respect to muscle recovery.

  9. So which of these simply tastes the best? (if all I want is milk for cereal) Regular powdered “skim” milk is not too tasty. A friend said he didn’t think Nido was too appealing (and hard to find). I assume goat’s milk is even harder. Hate to mail order a big canister just to taste it!

  10. Can anyone give me a specific drink, or additive, that is high in calories like milk that I may add to other foods such as granola and nuts and other non cooked foods?

    I haven’t drank milk in over 20+ years. I’m not lactose intolerant, I just do not like it.

    Any info would help

  11. When I saw this I was reminded of my son’s secret ‘energy recovery drink’ – chocolate milk. It was a secrete because he didn’t want to share with his young daughter. ha.

  12. I checked the Nutritional Information box on the package of my nonfat dry instant and it contained the sodium but not the potassium. Fresh nonfat did. Can these labels be trusted?

  13. I threw an almost full can of Nido in the trash last month. I couldn’t drink it or eat the cereal I used it with.

  14. For those of you seeking a quality low-fat instant milk powder, there’s a product called Milkman Milk that I’ve used for 30 years. It is equivalent to 2% milk and is the closest I’ve found to tasting like real, fresh milk. Conveniently, it comes in individual foil pouches that keep it fresh and are perfect to take with me when I go camping and hiking.

  15. You can also get powdered coconut or almond milk.

  16. Thanks for presenting multiple options here. Those of us in Oregon know that Nido is made by Nestle, who are trying to privatize water and Nestle does not believe that access to a water is a human right. They also are big in the bottled water business which is terrible for the environment.
    I’ll go with the goat milk. Until Nestle stops raping Mother Earth, you should avoid buying their goods, including Butterfingers.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *