Scaur Peak and The Fool Killer

The Fool Killer Summit
The Fool Killer Summit

I am really good at finding summit signs and canisters on trail-less bushwhack peaks. I have an uncanny ability to find herd paths, clear water sources, and even parking spaces in Harvard Square. I’m not sure if it’s attitude or karmic alignment or maybe my magnetic enthusiasm. Whatever, luck comes my way and I’m a good person to have on an expedition.

And we were very lucky yesterday on a long hike yesterday in the Sandwich Range of the White Mountains that included two White Mountain 4,000 footers and two trail-less bushwhacking peaks on the New Hampshire Hundred Highest list. There was very little ice and monorail left on the summits of North (4180′) and Middle (4140′) Tripyramid Mountains, we found an easy herd path on Scaur (pronounced like scower) Peak (3605′), and the woods were open and easy to walk while climbing The Fool Killer (3548′). Total hike time was 10 hours with 12 miles and 4,200′ of elevation gain/loss. Those were the lucky bits.

The weather was a little challenging though with temperatures just above freezing, low cloud cover, drizzle, freezing rain, sopping wet vegetation and about 2 dozen stream and brook crossings. In other words perfect hypothermia weather.

Weather Ravaged Tree on Scaur Peak
Weather Ravaged Tree on Scaur Peak

We were well prepared though. There were four hikers in my group, all Appalachian Mountain Club Hiking and Backpacking leaders, with tons of 4 season hiking and backpacking experience. We’re all in great hiking shape and know how to deal with these types of conditions very well: eat, drink, stay covered, and keep moving.  We also smelled horrible at the end of the hike and were wet to the bone. No bother though, we were having a blast.

We started our hike on Pine Bend Brook Trail which I’ve hiked once before in winter. It was  pleasant stroll through the woods, past gurgling streams and early string plant grown. We saw trillium, wild rose, and blooming hobble bush.  The trail was wet from the start, the clouds were low and we wondered whether we’d get any views later in the day.

While the Pine Bend Trail starts easy, it starts to climb after a while until you feel like you’re scrambling up a stairway made for a giant. Although I remembered that there were a few steep bits, the trail looked much different than I remembered without three additional feet of snow cloaking it. I’d rate this one strenuous.

Our original plan for this hike was to climb Pine Bend Trail to 3600 feet, bushwhack to Scaur Peak, return to the trail and climb North and Middle Tripyramid. From Middle, we’d backtrack to the Sabbaday Brook Trail, descend steeply to about 3,000 feet, bushwhack abut 1/2 mile up to The Fool Killer (3548′), and then reverse our route to get back to the van. We did all that except we hiked out Sabbaday Brook Trail instead, with a 1 mile road walk at the end to get back to our vehicle.

I’d originally been hesitant to commit to a Sabbaday Brook Trail exit for this hike because it has 8 major stream crossings and I’d been concerned that the water might be too high. There’s also the fact that many people are not comfortable with stream crossings at all. I can understand being afraid of a knee deep crossing, but peoples’ fears are often somewhat out of proportion to reality until they learn (through experience) how to scout a route and cross it. There are perfectly good reasons to avoid getting wet feet, but sometimes it’s unavoidable and not the end of the world as long as you know how to mitigate the hypothermia risks. It also feels great when it’s 80 degrees outside.

The hike over to Scaur Peak proved very easy. We found a herd path at 3600 feet on the bearing I’d planned (320 degrees) and followed it directly to the summit. There’s a sign at the summit but no canister. One down. From there, we turned around and reacquired the Pine Bend Trail, which intersected with the Mt Tripyramid Loop, shortly thereafter.

We followed that trail over the North and Middle Peaks, which were mostly clear of ice and monorail: we’d brought traction but didn’t need to put it on. There’s no snow in the surrounding woods at all. Unfortunately we were in cloud the entire time, so no views.

Stream Crossing on the Sabbaday Brook Trail
Stream Crossing on the Sabbaday Brook Trail

From Middle, we backtracked to the Sabbaday Book Trail Junction and descended very steeply to about 3,000 feet. There is some very wet and slippery slab on this slope and you need to be very cautious down-climbing it. Next came the Fool Killer bushwhack. Everything up to this point had been an appetizer: we were all on this hike to bag  this peak and experience the meaning of it’s strange name.

The name is not that odd if you think about the history of the White Mountains before it was ‘colonized’ by hiking trails. Back in those days, people had to bushwhack to get to Middle Tripyramid, but often found themselves short of their destination on top of The Fool Killer. The phrase “The Fool Killer” was originally used to describe a monumental piece of foolishness – such as climbing the wrong peak – and first appeared in print at the turn of the 20th century in a short story called The Fool Killer by Olivier Henry.

When we got to the base of The Fool Killer, I shot a bearing of 320 degrees and started climbing steeply up hill, my calves burning. They was a ton of decayed leaves and hummus on the hill and I found myself actually trying to kick steps (something you do in snow with mountaineering boots) in order to get a stable foothold on the slope. There was also ample evidence of widespread avalanche debris on  the slope which we had to pick our way around. But on the whole, the trees and vegetation on the peak are fairly open and it was possible to walk between them without the normal tearing of clothes and scratches that accompany denser vegetation.

Scaur-Fool Killer Loop
Scaur-Fool Killer Loop

It only took us 30 minute to climb the 600 off-feet to the summit ridge, which we then followed as it sloped up gently to the summit sign and canister. There is a faint herd path along the summit ridge although it’s covered with a substantial number of blown downs and debris.

We started out descent of the Fool Killer by 3:30 pm and were well on our way down the Sabbaday Brook trail by 4 pm, finishing the last 5 miles of our hike by 6:00. The water crossings weren’t that bad; my feed got wet because I was in trail runners but those of my compatriot’s, who were all wearing Gore-tex boots, stayed dry.

Needless to say, we were zonked by this hike and by the cold, wet weather; some of us, including myself, had been working long hours recently with little sleep, but I slept well after this hike. Very well.

Recommended Guidebooks and Maps:

Most Popular Searches

  • the fool killer nh


  1. Nice report! Were the streams crossed by wading thru or rock hopping? Doesn’t seem fun to just wade thru in wp boots regardless of gaiters – or else I just can’t get that tight of a seal….

    • Mostly walking over rocks that were covered by water. It wasn’t high enough to go over the ankle cuffs of the people wearing boots. Higher than normal, but not really that high for spring.

  2. “climbing the wrong peak ” reminds me of the story of the first attempts on Mt. Whitney: wrong peaks were climbed more than once.

  3. After reading reports from such noteworthy hikers as Rocket, Larisa and Becca, I decided the snowshoes could stay at home. They weren’t needed. There still are bits and pieces of monorail on the ridge, with a couple hundred feet or so nearing south peak, and a longer stretch nearing north peak, but it generally held me up and if it didn’t I could have just gotten off or at this time of year sunk in. The ledges on the steep section of Sabbaday had some wet areas that were slick, but with care negotiable without getting off to the side and contributing to widening the ledge. I hiked this trail once before but so long ago I didn’t remember anything other than I did it with Pepper’s predecessor Schnauzer, Shorty, the Lean Mean Hiking Machine. Sabbaday is a delightful trail as is the brook, the section swinging behind Fool Killer is still in hardwoods that are just beginning to leaf out and so the canopy is open, the crowds and bugs aren’t around yet, and the stream crossings and monorail just fun additions. This is a great time to hike this trail; even better when using some more of last year’s vacation.

  4. Would love to hike fool killer, but how do you know where to turn off sabbaday trail. Do you use an app and put in the coordinates? Willing to learn but unsure how to properly use a compass. I did take a basic compass class about 30 years ago but never used it, forgot how to use it.

    • You can figure it out with a compass, noting the change in the trails direction. But an app or gps will work too. Or an altimeter.

    • Pamela, you should re-learn the basics of map and compass. I use apps for convenience, but consider a paper map and compass to be the primary navigation tools. Anything electronic can fail. There are lots of tutorials on the Internet, but it may be best to take a course from a local hiking or orienteering club. Since navigation varies according to the type of terrain, learning from a club means adapting the course to local conditions. Since humans usually can’t travel as the crow flies on a straight bearing, you need to compensate for high mountains, rolling mountains, dessert, swamp, rockslides, etc. If you live in the same region as Phillip, he may be able to recommend a specific club. Don’t be lulled into thinking you can always stay on a well-marked trail. That doesn’t always work out.

  5. You are doing a great service for those of us who either off-trail hike a lot, or, are considering taking it up. Your detailed narrative (and I might add good humour!) complemented by bushwhack bearings and a track topo make for compelling reading.

    A typo I noticed – I believe your ‘320’ degree bearing to The Fool Killer summit should be 32 degrees.

  6. Apologize for my tardy feedback.

    I’m stumped on your 320 T confirmation.

    No question that’s your bearing to Scaur. However, assuming I’m reading your map right, you launched your bushwhack from the Sabbaday trail to the Fool Killer from the drainage separating it from the Tripyramid massif, near the base of an old slide. If so, that track bearing is very roughly in the NE direction, not NW (320 T).

    Your original plan seems to confirm: “Bushwhack northeast for about 3/8 mile on a bearing of 82 degrees to
    The Fool Killer”. I’m sticking to 30 – 32 degrees to the Fool Killer. We have to agree to disagree!

    Of much greater importance hope your ankle has healed considerably.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

error: Sorry. This is copyrighted material. No copying or reuse without express written permission.